A Tribute to Michel-Philippe Lerebours and his Haiti et Ses Peintres (1989)

Verlee Poupeye. © Cayman Islands National Museum

Haïti et ses peintres played an essential role in my development as a Caribbean art historian and provided an important counterpoint to much of what I had read about Haitian art up to that point. To this day, it remains one of the most comprehensive and academically rigorous studies on the subject, rivaled only by Carlo A. Célius’s recent book, Création plastique d’Haïti (2023).

At our request, Veerle Poupeye wrote an essay on Michel-Philippe Lerebours and his book Haïti et ses peintres.

My first encounters with Haitian art history were, predictably, via glossy coffee table books, several of them by Selden Rodman, that made it to Jamaica in the mid-1980s. These books featured undeniably exciting art, presented with great passion, but I soon realized that they offered me only a selective, externally generated and largely uncritical view of Haiti’s artistic production. 

My engagement with Haitian art gained depth in the early 1990s, when I became involved, as a writer and sometimes also as a curator, in several exhibitions of Caribbean art that were organized in North America and Europe and a few of them also in the Caribbean. When Thames & Hudson commissioned the first edition of my Caribbean Art book in 1995, I embarked on nearly two years of research and travel, which naturally also took me to Haiti. Gérald Alexis then accompanied me to the Musée d’Art Haitien to see an exhibition of work on paper by Lucien Price, one of the first in the Caribbean to turn to full abstraction in the 1940s, with a singular and distinctive style. I then also met Dr. Michel-Philippe Lerebours, who was the Director of the Musée d’Art Haitien, and acquired a copy of his two-volume book Haiti et Ses Peintres: De 1804 a 1980, Souffrances & Espoirs d’un Peuple (1989). It is still in my library today, regularly consulted as a vital reference book on Haitian art, and by now well-worn and with the binding falling apart.

A visit to Jamaica by the MUPANAH director Gérald Alexis, sometime in 1986 or 87, began to broaden my perspective. He brought a small exhibition of Haitian art to the Frame Centre Gallery in Kingston and presented a lecture, which I attended. The book La Peinture Haitienne/Haitian Arts (1986) by Marie-José Nadal-Gardère and Gerald Bloncourt, of which I acquired a copy around the same time, also conveyed that there was more to Haitian art. The first Caribbean Invitational exhibition at the National Gallery of Jamaica in 1988, where I served as the Assistant Curator at the time, included the work of Bernard Sejourné, who visited Jamaica for the exhibition (and who had studied with Colin Garland in Jamaica in the late 1960s). This exhibition should also have included paintings by Jasmin Joseph and Lafortune Felix but it was not possible for MUPANAH to ship their work to Jamaica at that time.

While all the published literature on Haitian art has, in various ways, contributed to my understanding of the subject, Lerebours’ Haiti et Ses Peintres was of a different order, based on a rigorously researched and written doctoral dissertation, with a significant focus on the social and historical context of art in Haiti. Alongside Lerebours’ own analysis, the book also reproduces key documents in Haiti’s art history, detailed chronologies and artist biographies, all extremely valuable resources. Haiti et Ses Peintres was a necessary part of my education as a Caribbean art historian, and an important counterpoint to much of what I had read about Haitian art up to that time. While of course not the first or only book on Haitian art by a Haitian author (Philippe Thoby-Marcelin’s Panorama de l’art haïtien was an early landmark, published in 1956), it remains to this day one of the most thorough, academically sound treatises on the subject, rivalled in that regard only by the recent Création Plastique d’Haïti (2023) by Carlo A. Célius.

Haiti et Ses Peintres is a demanding and lengthy read, with none of the seductive visual and narrative qualities of the earlier-mentioned coffee table publications on Haitian art. It presents a patriotic view of the subject, presented by an author who was determined to tell the whole story, in well-documented detail. The book is, as such, a retort to the reductive concept of a “Haitian art renaissance”, dominated by self-taught artists who had come out of nowhere, with the establishment of the Centre d’Art and expatriate impresarios such as Rodman as its principal catalysts. By demonstrating that there was a longer, broader and more complex Haitian art history, rooted in the self-empowering cultural dynamics of the Haitian Revolution and the reclamations of the Indigenist movement rather than expatriate discovery narratives, it represented, to put it in today’s terms, an important decolonial act. And importantly, he did so without dismissing or devaluing those self-taught artists who had come to international attention through the work of the early Centre d’Art.

Lerebours’ Haitian art history was one of several pioneering national, and usually expressly nationalist art histories that were produced in the Caribbean around that time. David Boxer’s pioneering work about Jamaican art history, which started in the mid-1970s, is another example. Lerebours and Boxer were among the first formally trained art historians from the Caribbean, who had returned home after attaining advanced degrees at prestigious universities abroad: Boxer at Johns Hopkins in the USA and Lerebours at the Sorbonne in France. While the cultural nationalist politics that informed the art-historical narratives they produced have been strongly criticized in recent decades, they were very necessary in their time, as important challenges to colonial and cultural imperialist perceptions, and remain as an important foundation for Caribbean art history today.

It was, however, hard for locally produced art historical narratives, such as Lerebours’ book or the many exhibition catalogues David Boxer produced for the National Gallery of Jamaica, to compete with the glossy, internationally published and circulated narratives that were produced by the likes of Rodman. Most of these pioneering national art histories were printed and published locally, modestly produced on low budgets with, for instance, only black and white illustrations, and with limited circulation. Most are out of print today and available only in specialized academic libraries and private book collections, which limits their access to all but the most determined researchers. This, in itself, speaks to uneven representational dynamics that have surrounded the production of Caribbean art history, in which scholars within the Caribbean itself have been at a distinct disadvantage due to limited local resources. There is, in fact, a need for some of these foundational texts to be brought into broader circulation, a challenge the Centre d’Art should perhaps look into, perhaps in the form of an anthology of key texts on Haitian art. 

While Haiti et Ses Peintres made an extremely valuable contribution, Lerebours’ account is not without limitations. With its focus on painting, as the defining art form, it ignores other important artistic expressions, such as sculpture or photography, and furthermore, and ironically, replicates a very Eurocentric conception of “fine art” that is not necessarily relevant in contexts such as Haiti’s.  Lerebours’ account is also strongly focused on artists who practiced in Haiti itself, and he pays insufficient attention to the broader contexts and the important interactions with what was happening elsewhere in the Caribbean, such as Cuba and Jamaica, in African-American art, or in the emerging Haitian diaspora. Lerebours discusses artists who made their careers between Haiti and other locations, such as Luce Turnier, but curiously he barely mentions Hervé Télémaque, who was a figure of note in Europe’s Surrealism and Nouveau Réalisme. The reason may be that did not have a strong presence in Haiti (although he was briefly associated with the Centre d’Art as a young artist) and that his work is not as recognizably “Haitian” as that of his counterparts (although there are in fact frequent references). And Haiti et Ses Peintres does, of course, not speak about the developments that have taken place in Haiti and its diaspora since 1980, as those were beyond the chronological scope of the book. These gaps have, however, been covered since then by other authors, such as Alexis, Célius, Jerry Philogene, in the diaspora, and Sterlin Ulysse and Ervenshy Hugo Jean-Louis in Haiti.

That Haitian art is discussed in isolation from a broader context does not mean that the book does not contain material that is of value beyond its subject. It is through reading Haiti et Ses Peintres, for instance, that I first became aware that the lithographer and Jamaica’s first photographer, the Frenchman Adolphe Duperly, had lived and worked in Haiti, teaching lithography at the Lycée National, before moving to Jamaica in 1824. This was not known in Jamaica, where it was assumed that he had come from France directly. After he moved from Haiti to Jamaica, via Santiago de Cuba, Duperly furthermore married a woman of creole Haitian descent via Trinidad, Louise Desnoes. This speaks to the complex movement of Haitians in the Caribbean region and beyond, in the aftermath of the revolution, and the general interconnectedness of Haitian and other Caribbean history and art history.

It nonetheless remains that Haiti et ses Peintres is a monumental and seminal work, which provides a solid foundation for an equitable, accurate and inclusive Haitian art history. The discipline of art history in the Caribbean and beyond owes him a debt of gratitude.

Veerle Poupeye

Veerle Poupeye is a Belgian-Jamaican art historian, curator, and critic specializing in Caribbean art and visual culture. She lives in Kingston, Jamaica, and currently works as an independent curator, researcher, author, and cultural consultant.